Sunday, April 5, 2015

Is Brave New World a tragedy? If so, how? If not, why?Citations, please!

No.  Brave New World is a comedy.
 Comedy is focused on society, while tragedy is focused on the individual.  Clearly,
Huxley's targets are societal.


Brave New
World
is a dystopian science fiction satire to be exact.  The novel parodies
several people, places, and things--namely totalitarianism.  Satires are meant to
ridicule and exaggerate human weakness and folly.  Huxley's attacks are not subtle: he
names names (Ford, Lenin, Marx, etc...)


A tragedy is much
more focused than Brave New World.  Tragedies are streamlined for
disaster from the start.  Brave New World doesn't even introduce
its most important character, John, until about half-way through the novel.
 Brave New World lacks the unity of place, unity of action, and
unity of time to be a tragedy.  Brave New World is a novel of
ideas: it doesn't conform to any rules or genres.  In fact, it tries to break
them.


John is certainly not a tragic hero: he is too naive
and immature, not noble enough, has too many weaknesses.  He's more of a Byronic
Hero--wounded by love, self-destructive.  He does not have a tragic flaw or make a
mistake in judgement that leads directly to his suffering and death.  He's more of a
victim of social evil.


Although the novel has some tragic
elements (John's death), the novel--as a whole--is definitely not a tragedy.  Here's
some reasons why:


Tragedy
VS. Comedy


  1. acceptance of life
    vs. rejection of life

  2. shows
    man's great potential vs. shows man's limitations,
    foibles

  3. shows the dignity and courage  of
    man vs. mocks excess

  4. high
    character vs. exaggeration and
    caricature

  5. man in godlike state vs.
    folly, incongruity of human
    behavior

  6. hero has a tragic flaw vs.
    hero has many
    weaknesses

No comments:

Post a Comment

In Act III, scene 2, why may the establishment of Claudius's guilt be considered the crisis of the revenge plot?

The crisis of a drama usually proceeds and leads to the climax.  In Shakespeare's Hamlet , the proof that Claudius is guilty...